On the 83rd listen it occurred to me that Imperial Garden from Star Ocean 5 was no good. I'm not sure how I didn't notice the previous 82 times, but I guess it grew tiresome in a drip by drip manner and this time was the straw that broke the camel's back. Some songs grow on you over time, and others turn sour. It's the way of life. Back down to 5479.
I watched Red Dawn, but I can't recommend it. The scenario is preposterous. The Soviet Union didn't have the strength to invade and occupy America with conventional forces. Our military was vastly superior to theirs. Besides, if they had managed it somehow, we would have resorted to nuclear weapons, and they know we would have, which is why it's preposterous for any war to break out in the first place. No one wants to die for nothing. But even accepting the setting at face value, it's tiresome how all these boys-forced-to-be-warriors would cry at the drop of a hat. Oh no, a parent died, cry cry. Oh no, a comrade in arms died, cry cry. Oh no, I had to execute a traitor, cry cry. Stop crying you sissies. This is fucking war. Get over it like every other warrior on Earth and go kill some more bad guys. You don't see people crying left and right in Midway or Enemy at the Gates. You just see people getting to work and killing the opponent. If you want to make a war movie, make your characters act like they're in a war, not a drama club.
Ready Player One had some cool references -- Gundam, Firefly, Akira, Back to the Future, etc. But the actual plot was silly. 2045 isn't going to be a massive slum with virtual reality. It's either going to be a perfectly nice place or a crater, based on our foreign policy with China and Russia. And there still won't be any virtual reality, because virtual reality is way harder than movies pretend.
Rio Bravo is also a no go. It had some pretty faces and the plot wasn't exactly bad, but it took way too long and was way too repetitive. What that movie desperately needed was an editor.
At least I could sit through those movies, others were so bad I couldn't get past the first five minutes, like Rocky and Dunkirk.
The ending to the Shingeki no Kyojin manga was a bait and switch. The entire time the manga debated how best to deal with the Eldians. Eldians can turn into Titans and destroy the world, which makes them a net negative for non-Eldians. (Even if most Eldians are well intentioned, it would only take one Eldian once to destroy the world, which is unacceptable.) The options were quite simple -- Eldia could take out the outside world, the outside world could take out Eldia, or everyone could agree to live in harmony and somehow all future threats could be averted by the power of love. Those were the only 3 options all manga long. But in the very last chapter, the author, out of nowhere, with no foreshadowing and with no basis, invented a 4th solution, if Mikasa kills Eren then Ymir agrees to deactivate the Titan power and Eldians all go back to normal, happily ever after. So the entire debate and the entire struggle of all the characters was rendered moot by this sudden new easy solution. That's called a bait and switch. The story posed an interesting moral dilemma -- what should people do in a case like this? And ultimately the author flinched away from answering it, and instead magically solved the dilemma via divine intervention. So we're still left with no answer to the central question that supposedly the entire manga existed for. What should people have done? What a cop out. If you aren't willing to answer your own story's questions, if you don't have the moral courage to take a stance, then don't pose the question in the first place. Once posed, the author has an onus to answer. It's like a mystery with no solution or a riddle with no solution, you simply aren't allowed to make those moves. It ruins the compact between writer and reader.
The same thing happened with To Love ru Darkness. The author posed a question, what would make the characters happier, Rito starting a galactic harem, or Rito staying on Earth and living a normal monogamous life with Haruna? The manga ended in a stalemate. Rito tried to go with Haruna, but found himself too sad to actually go through with it. So in the end what's the solution? Neither? The author must make a choice! Either one would be fine if they have the moral courage to stick with it, but vacillating even on the very last panel? Who does that benefit? For what purpose was the story even written? A story is about decisions and their consequences. If you refuse to make a decision there is no story. Likewise, if the consequences are completely separate from people's decisions, like with Shingeki no Kyojin, again there is no story. I wish pro authors would at least reach the starting line of storytelling 101.
In more productive news, I made two edits to chapter 41 of '100 Waifus'. I'll highlight the new text in bold and show off the changes in context:
"Okay, my next wish is pretty silly. But could you give all my children the option to look like the characters in the stories they were named after? And could you give me a sort of augmented reality where they all look like that to me whether they like it or not? It would also be nice if their voices were changed to sound like their original voice actor source. I can always turn it off if needs be but just when I see them around town it would be nice to meet the characters I always envisioned them to be.""What about when their source characters could transform?" Cute-sama asked."So like Gohan could be seen as Super Saiyan 2 or Kanade could be seen as Cure Rhythm? That would be so awesome! Let's make that a third option I can switch between when looking at them."
"I guess. . .it would be nice if entropy didn't ultimately devour and destroy everything we've ever produced, rendering it all pointless." I said."The laws of physics are necessary for life so I can't adjust them. But I can promise you nothing of value from this universe will be lost. I can spin out new universes for your culture to continue in if there's still more to see from it. And if there's nothing left to see but lots to gaze fondly back upon, rest assured that I exist in a plane beyond entropy and I will remember all of you, everything you ever felt or thought or did, every sight there was to see. Everything that's ever been continues to live through me." Cute-sama promised."I want to impregnate my wives naturally but it would still be nice to be able to sex select the children that come from them." I entrusted the fate of the universe to Cute, who seemed to have things well in hand, and went back to my specialty of petty selfish desires.
No comments:
Post a Comment