Hana wa Saku, Shura no Gotoku: A very pretty show with likable talented girls. This is another 'cute girls doing cool things' series, but this time it's recitation, as opposed to golf or figure skating. Pass.
Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata: At least the first episode was excellent, challenging today's moral norms against incest in a very clever way -- what if the siblings live together forever but don't have sex? What's the complaint then? No deformed babies to whine about this time. Pass.
Honey Lemon Soda: Why do people take exception with the male's blond hair when literally everyone in the anime has strangely colored hair? Why is the heroine so useless that all she can do is stand or sit silently and cry? And the biggest question of all, why is the only possible way for a girl to become romantically attracted to a guy is if he saves her from immediate physical danger? Where does that leave the other 99% of men who are not conveniently situated near crime victims? Fail.
Around 40 Otoko no Isekai Tsuuhan: A surprisingly good series. An isekai'd guy is given the cheat power of being able to shop for Earth goods that instantly teleport to his new world. The new world is obviously lacking in many Earth goods, so he can sell them at a high price. Then he can exchange the silver and gold he earns in his new world for Yen, where silver and gold are priced highly, and make an overall dramatic profit. With this simple cheat he's basically infinitely wealthy while still having access to all modern conveniences. This makes him attractive to the ladies as well. (Girls really are simple, aren't they?) A light-spirited story about doing business in another world is a refreshing change from all the overpowered beatdown combat isekai tropes. Pass.
Kanteishi: So this boy is tortured for the entire episode due to foolishly deciding to dungeon crawl a dungeon that's way stronger than him. But a dryad of the World Tree decides to bail him out for whatever reason. It's implied in the opening and ending that from here he's granted free power from the dryad and then goes and wreaks havoc on monsters and impresses society from here. I'm not interested. The results have nothing to do with the decisions the character made so it's completely meaningless. I wish a dryad would randomly take pity on me and give me ultimate power too, but that's not how reality or the human condition works. . .Fail.
From Bureacrat to Villainess: Like every other villainess genre story, I fail to see the point. If the lone obstacle in the story, the villainess, is removed, then what is there left to talk about? Overcoming nothing? Achieving nothing? If the villainess is nice then okay, case closed. The story evaporates on its own. Fail.
Welcome to Japan Ms. Elf: Marie is one of the most beautiful elves I've ever seen. It's a shame she's stranded in such an awful show. Fail.
Farmagia: Take a lot of tired old gags from previous Hiro Mashima works, plus a lot of tired old character models from previous Hiro Mashima works, and some tired old plotlines from previous Hiro Mashima works, and you get Farmagia. What a mess. Fail.
Ubel Blatt: Men who are rude to women are not automatically 'cool.' They're just jerks. Fail.
Guild Receptionist: This story is so well animated. Why must it waste all that budget on the same joke for the entire 24 minutes of the first ep? It was funny the first time -- not the 80th. Fail.
Sakamoto Days: Not only is the main character fat, he's also silent and only talks by pointing at written signs. It's ridiculous. This kind of behavior, which is entirely voluntary on his part, is completely anti-social. Does he think his wife and daughter enjoy their fat silent father figure? Why should they have to put up with his random eccentricities? Fail.
A-Rank Party wa Ridatsu: A surprisingly decent show given its premise. This very good looking red mage decides he could find a better party and hooks up with a bunch of his former female students who are all hot and very admiring towards him. It's like paradise compared to his old party. I just hope he isn't a pussy like all Japanese characters are and refuses to touch any of them moving forward. . .Pass.
Mahoutsukai Precure Mirai Days: I'm always leery of sequels to stories that never intended to have sequels. This one doesn't do anything offensive, but it also doesn't do anything promising, so I can't tell if it lives up to the original. For now it's 'good' and we'll wait and see if it's 'great.' Pass.
Sentai Red Isekai: What if a Power Ranger went to an isekai? This burning question at the heart of all philosophy is now answered -- a rather hilarious and exciting fusion is born. Pass.
That's the full winter season. 18 series for now, which will drop down to 17 once Arifureta ends. That's a fine season as far as quantity goes, but it's a bit lacking in quality. No more Bleach or Fairy Tail or Sword Art Online to accompany us like last Fall. But life can't always be that good.
* * *
Here's the good anime that's currently airing this season and is worth at least a try, in the order of how exciting each episode is week to week (not in the order of how good the series is overall, which would favor older/longer series too much):
1. Ao no Hako
2. 100 Kanojo S2
3. Class no Daikirai na Joshi to Kekkon suru Koto ni Natta
4. Wonderful Precure
5. Grisaia Phantom Trigger
6. Ave Mujica
7. Mahoutsukai Precure Mirai Days
8. Arifureta S3
9. Hana wa Saku, Shura no Gotoku
10. Dragon Ball Daima
11. Medalist
12. Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata
13. Sentai Red Isekai
14. Around 40 Otoko no Isekai Tsuuhan
15. Sorairo Utility
16. A-Rank Party wa Ridatsu
17. My Happy marriage S2
18. Rurouni Kenshin Remake Kyoto-hen